But Did They Like It?!?

There is certainly no lack of opinion on this podcast, and this page is the perfect place to discover them all. Here you’ll discover our ratings for every wine we’ve reviewed, accompanied by our collective view on whether a particular bottle was a waste of our wine. Also on display, will be the bottles that have made their way into our coveted wine fridges.

Happy Sipping!

A Brief Reminder

  • Wine Fridge: The highest place of honor in our ranking system. Only 3 slots available for only the finest of wine.
  • A Must Share: Excellent wine thats just too good to keep to ourselves.
  • A Casual Sipper: No fuss, no frills, just an easy wine to enjoy anytime.
  • A Backup Wine: Not the first choice or second or third, but hey, it gets the job done when needed.
  • Drian Wine: Life’s too short for bad wine. Down the drain it goes!

The Wine Fridges

Aaron’s wine Fridge

2018 Beronia Rioja Reserva

2022 Turley Juvenile Zinfandel

2021 Domdechant Werner Riesling, Trocken

Colin’S wine Fridge

2017 St. Giorgio Chianti Classico riserva

De saint-gall CHampagne

2023 Laurent Delaunay Macon-Villages

Joel’s Wine Fridge

Robert Groffier Bourgogne

2018 Beronia Rioja Reserva

2022 Turley Juvenile Zinfandel

All Wine Reviews

Wine NameType RegionAaron's RatingColin's RatingJoel's RatingFinal RatingEpisode Link
2023 Alessandria Barbera d'AlbaRedAlbaA Must ShareA Must ShareA Must ShareA Mus ShareSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2018 Marqués de la Concordia Rioja Viña Alarde ReservaRedRiojaA Must ShareA Must ShareA Must ShareA Must ShareSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Lamothe-Vincent Reserve BordeauxRedBordeauxCasual SipperCasual SipperA Must ShareCasual SipperSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Mucchietto Soave DOCWhiteSoaveBackup WineBackup WineCasual SipperBackup WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Educated Guess, Napa Valley Cabernet SauvignonRedNapa ValleyA Must ShareA Must ShareA Must ShareA Must ShareSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Château d'Esclans Whispering AngelRoséCotes de ProvanceCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2020 Rectoral de Amandi Heroic Edition MenciaRedGaliciaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Dr. Heidemanns-Bergweiler RieslingWhiteMoselA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2019 Mascota Vinyards Unánime Gran Vino TintoRedArgentina/MendozaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
Marie De Moy Grand Cru ChampagneSparklingChampagneA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 E. Guigal Côtes Du Rhône BlancWhiteCôtes Du RhôneCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Abstained due to illnessCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Cantina Zaccagnin Montepulicanio d' AbruzzoRedAbruzzoCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2020 Ruffino Riserva Ducale Chianti ClassicoRedChianti ClassicoA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
Hope Family Wines Havester Cabernet SauvgnonRed
Central CoastCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Spotify
Apple
YouTube
La Vostra Prosecco Superiore DOCGSparklingProsecco Superiore DOCGA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2020 Domaine Des Versauds Morgon RedBeaujolais A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Blaauwklippen Stellenbosch Chenin BlancWhite
StellenboschA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Turley Juvenile ZinfandelRed
California
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineWine Fridge WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
Cassillero Del DiabloRedChileDrain WineDrain WineDrain WineDrain WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
19 Crimes FrankensteinRedSouth Eastern AustraliaBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2020 Chateau de Chantegrive Graves BordeauxRedBordauxA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 San Gregorio El Vergal TempranilloRedCalatayudCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Laurent Delaunay Mâcon-Villages Les GrappillagesWhiteMâcon-VillagesA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
AppleYouTube
2021 Knappstein ShirazRedClare Valley
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Blue Canyon Pinot NoirRedMontereyBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineCasual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2020 Montresor Capitel Della Crosara Valpolicella RipassoRedValpolicellaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Planeta Red BlendRedCerasuolo Di VittoriaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2020 URO Finca Lan Rana TempranilloRedToroA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Casual Sipper (Formerly: Counter Wine)Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Famiglia Castellani St. Giorgio Vermentino Toscana IGTWhiteTuscanyA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Jean-Claude Debeaune Beaujolais-VillagesRedBeaujolaisBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2018 Robert Groffier BourgogneRedBurgundyA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
De Saint-Gall Premier Cru ChampagneSparklingChampagneA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Maraso Gran BlendRedArgentinaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2018 Quinta Das Carvalhas Touriga NacionalRedDouro
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Radius Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon RedColumbia ValleyA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Stags' Leap ChardonnayWhiteNapa ValleyWine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Caliveda Pino Noir ReserveRedCaliforniaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Geil Gewürztraminer KabinettWhiteRheinhessenA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineSpotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Val Do Sosego Albariño WhiteRias BaixasA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2022 Donachiara Epatia FinaoWhiteFiano Di Avellino D.O.C.GA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2023 Josh Cellars SeasweptWhiteCaliforniaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
YouTube
2021 Grounded by Josh Phelps Cabernet SauvignonRedCaliforniaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2022 Le Pré Vajour Cabernet FrancRedChinonBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineSpotify
Apple
2021 Albino Armani Orange From The Basment Pino GrigioOrangedelle VenezieA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2018 Finca Bacara Tabá MonestrellRedJumillaA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineWine Fridge WineWine Fridge WineSpotify
Apple
2022 Ferrari-Carano Fumé BlancWhiteCaliforniaBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineSpotify
Apple
Casal Garcia Vinho VerdeWhiteVinho VerdeA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2022 Davey Family ShirazRedMcLaren ValeA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2017 Famiglia Castellani St. Giorgio Chianti Classico RiservaRedChianti ClassicoA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Wine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2020 Lucien Albrecht Pinot Gris TraditionWhiteAlsaceA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2022 Chateau De Thau Cotes De BourgRedBordeauxWine Fridge WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
Giesen Riesling Non-AlcoholicWhiteMarlboroughNon-Alcoholic Shelf
Drain WineNon-Alcoholic Shelf
Non-Alcoholic Shelf
Spotify
Apple
Loius Bouillot Crémant De Bourgogne Blanc De BlancsSparklingBurgundyA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
2021 Carmen Merlot Gran ReservaRedMaipo ChileDrain WineDrain WineBackup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineDrain WineSpotify
Apple
Vueve Clicqout Yellow Label ChampagneSparklingChampagneA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Backup Wine (Formerly: Closet WineA Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
A Must Share (Formerly: Kitchen Table Wine)
Spotify
Apple
Scroll to Top